Comparisons

Etsy vs Amazon Handmade vs Shopify for Selling Crafts

Quick answer: For most crafters, start with Etsy. Fees are low (about 10% per sale plus $0.20 per listing), and shoppers there are already searching for handmade goods. Amazon Handmade gives you huge reach, but it takes a 15% referral fee and you need approval. Shopify gives you full control with no marketplace commission. You pay a monthly plan, though, and you have to bring your own traffic.

EtsyAmazon HandmadeShopify
TypeMarketplaceMarketplace (approval required)Your own store
Listing fee$0.20 per listing, renews every 4 monthsNoneNone
Sales fee6.5% of order total incl. shipping15% referral fee (or $0.30 minimum per unit)No platform commission with Shopify Payments
Payment processing3% + $0.25 (US)Included in referral feeCard processing fees apply
Monthly feeNone required$39.99 Professional plan waived for approved Handmade sellersMonthly plan required
Built-in buyersYes, handmade-focusedYes, very largeNo, you drive traffic
Best forBeginners, gifts, personalized itemsHigher-volume makers with good marginsEstablished brands with an audience

US fees checked November 2026 (see Sources below). Etsy Offsite Ads charge 15% on orders that come from those ads, or 12% once your shop has made $10,000+ in the past 365 days, capped at $100 per order.

Etsy: best for beginners

On a typical US sale, Etsy charges a $0.20 listing fee, a 6.5% transaction fee on the full order total, and 3% + $0.25 for payment processing. That comes to roughly 10% before ads. Etsy shoppers are already looking for handmade, vintage and personalized products, so a new shop gets found more easily.

Pros: low entry cost, buyers who want handmade, simple setup. Cons: fees stack up; Offsite Ads can take 12–15% on some sales; lots of competition.

Amazon Handmade: best for reach

To sell on Amazon Handmade, you apply and show that your items are handmade. Handmade needs a Professional selling plan ($39.99/month). Amazon says it waives that monthly fee for approved Handmade sellers after the first month. Amazon takes a referral fee of 15% or $0.30 per unit, whichever is greater, and its Handmade page lists no separate payment processing fee.

Pros: massive audience, Prime eligibility, simple fee math. Cons: highest per-sale fee, strict approval, less control over your brand, buyers who expect fast shipping.

Shopify: best for brand control

Shopify is your own store. You pick the design and own the customer list. There’s no marketplace commission when you use Shopify Payments, but you pay a monthly plan plus card processing fees. The big trade-off is that there are no built-in buyers. You need social media, email, SEO or ads to bring people in.

Pros: full control, your own customer data, better margins at scale. Cons: monthly cost, and getting traffic is all on you.

Fees on a $40 sale (US, no ads)

PlatformApproximate feesYou keep (before materials)
Etsy$0.20 + $2.60 + $1.45 = $4.25About $35.75
Amazon Handmade15% = $6.00About $34.00
ShopifyCard processing only (plus monthly plan)Depends on plan and volume

Which should you pick?

  • Just starting: Etsy.
  • Selling at volume with healthy margins: add Amazon Handmade.
  • You have an audience (Instagram, TikTok, email list): Shopify, often alongside Etsy.

FAQ

Is Etsy or Amazon Handmade cheaper?

Usually Etsy, at about 10% per sale vs 15%, before Offsite Ads.

Do I need approval to sell on Etsy?

No. Etsy doesn’t require approval. Amazon Handmade does.

Can I sell on all three?

Yes. A common setup is Etsy for discovery and Shopify for repeat customers.

Does Shopify take a percentage of sales?

There’s no marketplace commission when you use Shopify Payments. Card processing fees still apply.

Sources

About Devin haney

Writes practical side hustle guides for GetSideHustles.

More guides by this author · Our editorial standards

Ready for your next step?

Use the Side Hustle Finder to match ideas to your budget and schedule.

Take the quiz