Quick answer: For most crafters, start with Etsy. Fees are low (about 10% per sale plus $0.20 per listing), and shoppers there are already searching for handmade goods. Amazon Handmade gives you huge reach, but it takes a 15% referral fee and you need approval. Shopify gives you full control with no marketplace commission. You pay a monthly plan, though, and you have to bring your own traffic.
| Etsy | Amazon Handmade | Shopify | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Marketplace | Marketplace (approval required) | Your own store |
| Listing fee | $0.20 per listing, renews every 4 months | None | None |
| Sales fee | 6.5% of order total incl. shipping | 15% referral fee (or $0.30 minimum per unit) | No platform commission with Shopify Payments |
| Payment processing | 3% + $0.25 (US) | Included in referral fee | Card processing fees apply |
| Monthly fee | None required | $39.99 Professional plan waived for approved Handmade sellers | Monthly plan required |
| Built-in buyers | Yes, handmade-focused | Yes, very large | No, you drive traffic |
| Best for | Beginners, gifts, personalized items | Higher-volume makers with good margins | Established brands with an audience |
US fees checked November 2026 (see Sources below). Etsy Offsite Ads charge 15% on orders that come from those ads, or 12% once your shop has made $10,000+ in the past 365 days, capped at $100 per order.
Etsy: best for beginners
On a typical US sale, Etsy charges a $0.20 listing fee, a 6.5% transaction fee on the full order total, and 3% + $0.25 for payment processing. That comes to roughly 10% before ads. Etsy shoppers are already looking for handmade, vintage and personalized products, so a new shop gets found more easily.
Pros: low entry cost, buyers who want handmade, simple setup. Cons: fees stack up; Offsite Ads can take 12–15% on some sales; lots of competition.
Amazon Handmade: best for reach
To sell on Amazon Handmade, you apply and show that your items are handmade. Handmade needs a Professional selling plan ($39.99/month). Amazon says it waives that monthly fee for approved Handmade sellers after the first month. Amazon takes a referral fee of 15% or $0.30 per unit, whichever is greater, and its Handmade page lists no separate payment processing fee.
Pros: massive audience, Prime eligibility, simple fee math. Cons: highest per-sale fee, strict approval, less control over your brand, buyers who expect fast shipping.
Shopify: best for brand control
Shopify is your own store. You pick the design and own the customer list. There’s no marketplace commission when you use Shopify Payments, but you pay a monthly plan plus card processing fees. The big trade-off is that there are no built-in buyers. You need social media, email, SEO or ads to bring people in.
Pros: full control, your own customer data, better margins at scale. Cons: monthly cost, and getting traffic is all on you.
Fees on a $40 sale (US, no ads)
| Platform | Approximate fees | You keep (before materials) |
|---|---|---|
| Etsy | $0.20 + $2.60 + $1.45 = $4.25 | About $35.75 |
| Amazon Handmade | 15% = $6.00 | About $34.00 |
| Shopify | Card processing only (plus monthly plan) | Depends on plan and volume |
Which should you pick?
- Just starting: Etsy.
- Selling at volume with healthy margins: add Amazon Handmade.
- You have an audience (Instagram, TikTok, email list): Shopify, often alongside Etsy.
FAQ
Is Etsy or Amazon Handmade cheaper?
Usually Etsy, at about 10% per sale vs 15%, before Offsite Ads.
Do I need approval to sell on Etsy?
No. Etsy doesn’t require approval. Amazon Handmade does.
Can I sell on all three?
Yes. A common setup is Etsy for discovery and Shopify for repeat customers.
Does Shopify take a percentage of sales?
There’s no marketplace commission when you use Shopify Payments. Card processing fees still apply.